“Jenn Colella delivers on the promise of her Broadway debut in Urban Cowboy with a heartbreaking performance as Cleo. Her country twang of a singing voice is perfect for 'Don't Think Twice, It's All Right.' She is also ideal in her duets with Michael Arden.”— Rob Stevens, Theatremania

“...Colella's studding rock voice and considerable natural likeability seem more intense with every new Broadway show she does.”— Matthew Murray, Talkin' Broadway

“...the cast is well stocked with strong voices and winning personalities. Colella and Karl, in particular, make sexy, dynamic leads.”— David Rooney, Variety

“...Jenn Colella, the lead, is a real star: gamin beauty, totally rivetting charisma, with a fine voice and an amazingly fluid body.”— Clive Barnes, New York Post